Loading...
 

Tiki vs MediaWiki


MediaWiki is a free software wiki package originally written for Wikipedia. It is now used by several other projects of the non-profit Wikimedia Foundation and by many other wikis. Since MediaWiki is so well-known, a frequent question is: What is the difference between MediaWiki and Tiki?

Nobody ever got fired for picking MediaWiki

MediaWiki is the most deployed wiki engine. As such, it enjoys a massive virtuous circle . However, since MediaWiki is primarily developed to run Wikipedia (and your project is not Wikipedia!), it may very well be that MediaWiki is not your best choice. Many people pick MediaWiki just because so many others do. Similar to "Nobody ever got fired for picking IBM ", often, people will not go through a proper analysis and consider other wiki engines such as DokuWiki, TWiki, XWiki, MoinMoin, etc. Since it's so well-known, you will likely need arguments to explain this. This page is here to help :-)

If you are already using MediaWiki and you are thinking of moving to Tiki, you can use the MediaWiki importer

Video interview from OSCON 2011

Similar

Different

Wiki Matrix

Compare them at http://www.wikimatrix.org/compare/Tiki-Wiki-CMS-Groupware+MediaWiki

Active contributors

Number of contributors who made changes to the project source code each month.
Image

Tiki is in red


The green line includes contributions to the MediaWiki core and to the extensions .

Commits

Commits to the project source code each month.
Image

Tiki is in red


The green line includes contributions to the MediaWiki core and to the extensions .

About MediaWiki as the de facto standard wiki engine

Evan Prodromou, MediaWiki developer wrote:
So, one thing to note is the great Wiki:TopTenWikiEngines list, which does a nice job of narrowing down the field of contenders for new implementers.

I think choosing MediaWiki as the de facto standard wiki engine is a horrible idea:

*MediaWiki development has always and will always be focused on Wikipedia.
*It is difficult to extend.
*The code is indefensibly badly written. I know – I’ve written quite a bit of it.
*It is difficult to skin.
*It requires a database.
*No WikiWords.
*It is so slow that it requires tons of Squid server, memory cache add-ons, etc., etc. just to run correctly. The code is developed as if you have all these extra servers available, and if you don’t they’re stubbed out.

That’s not to say that I don’t think that MediaWiki is important for any discussion of wiki technical interaction, but I don’t think MediaWiki is the VHS of the wiki world. I do think that wiki engines should have an easy way to turn on “MediaWiki syntax mode”, so that admins who know they’ll have a WikiPedia-savvy community can easily get started that way. (I think PmWiki 2 will have MediaWiki syntax as an option.) But as we move into the WysiwygWiki era, I think that’s going to be less important.


Source:
http://www.communitywiki.org/TooManyWikiEngines

Alias

Subscribe to Tiki Newsletters! [Toggle] [Toggle Vertically]

Delivered fresh to your email inbox!
Newsletter subscribe icon
Don't miss major announcements and other news!
Contribute to Tiki

Why Register? [Toggle] [Toggle Vertically]

Register at tiki.org and you'll be able to use it at any *.tiki.org site, thanks to the InterTiki feature. A valid email address is required to receive site notifications and occasional newsletters. You can opt out of these items at any time.

Shoutbox [Toggle] [Toggle Vertically]

Torsten Fabricius, 09:54 UTC, Wed 19 Feb 2014: Hello everybody, please mind the ((TikiFestSysadmin2014)) in August. Mainly meant for the Sysadmins, which are located in and near Germany (and France), active community members from Canada are expected to be attending.
luciash d' being, 12:28 UTC, Wed 01 Jan 2014: Happy New Year ! :-)
luciash d' being, 14:00 UTC, Sun 27 Oct 2013: @ricks99: there is a regression bug in Tiki resetting the avatars to the default one imho
Rick, 16:56 UTC, Wed 31 Jul 2013: What happened to the avatars?
Jonny Bradley, 12:44 UTC, Wed 10 Apr 2013: Biggest TikiFest in ages starts tomorrow [Link]