Re: Registered users can't post in forums
I agree, Route66rambler. The integration of the wiki and forums is a winner. But it is not integrated enough at the moment and I want people to have the ability to actively respond to the contents of the wiki, without giving them the ability to change the wiki page (and the related headache with its administration and monitoring, not to mention the security and abuse).
What I plan to do (after I move the sites to the dedicated server that is), to change the SMF here and there. The search button will stay as it is in SMF, but I add an additional button which says Search Wiki. I believe that there is even a mod for that.
Tiki integration with the SMF is also simple to do. I plan to use the Dynamic content for that. I plan to create dynamic content for each wiki page (even using IFRAME in some cases to show the forum posts). In this way, every wiki page has a link with the forum. It also will display posts for the subject. Under that (IFRAME), there will be a link to open a new window to the forum. That kind of integration is easy to implement in this way. Long live the dynamic content!
There are also several mods available for the SMF (especially the latest version 2.x), where it is easy to integrated with the content of other sites, like our TikiWiki. IFRAME is the keyword here again, as are the mods for custom links.
TinyPortal is great and their newest version is very advanced and stable, for the SMF 1.x. For the SMF 2.x, there is still no version.
There are mods for the SMF, which enables every post a link to the Wiki automatically. Also it is possible to 'embed' Wiki content into each page at the SMF. And I intent to use those features.
The only negative thing I see with the integration is that it does not share the users databases, even when I will import members from the Wiki to the SMF n the beginning, but that will not cover the new users after that.
But experience learns that people do not mind to register again if it is interesting for them. And after they are registered, there are always cookies to keep them logged in.
Summarizing, what I look for integrated forums is reasonable simple to implement with an external forum like the SMF. I think it is a question of creativity to get such integration. If you want, we can brainstorm together per email or Skype (Username: wim.vincken) to get the integration working.
I don't see the problems fixed for the first weeks ore longer with the forums in the wiki and I really like to h ave more functionality about the way how the forums are integrated. I even prefer to remove the forums in my TikiWiki and get the SMF integrated instead.
I'm a specialist in Web 2.0, and my job is increasing Internet traffic to websites to increase sales. Using TikiWiki is nice, because I can create communities for certain customers to get more traffic with this software.
I know that the wiki-forums will not be able to attract more members, because its functionality is too poor and Internet users demand certain things before they register or visit as lurkers and come back each day.
Integration is nice, but not enough.
Wim