Loading...
 
Skip to main content

Custom Share Module 0.1dev

History: Tiki Suite brainstorming

Preview of version: 79

This page is to discuss/debate/brainstorm on
  • what needs should be covered and
  • which components should be part of the suite


Related: Components and criteria and features.



Global

Backup-FileSync

Server

Virtualization

LDAP-Mail-XMPP/Jabber

cdrwhite runs several boxes with OpenLDAP, postfix, courier IMAP (courier authdaemond offers LDAP but also MySQL: we could also use Tiki-based authentication + vmail for that combination)

  • There currently exists an inherent issue with LDAP and recent Ubuntu's OpenSSH pkg: due to the drop of OpenSSL in favor of GnuTLS it does not LDAP ssh keys are not supported.


Ejabberd seems the defacto choice at the moment, it features complete LDAP integration, web ui and many other modules. All this with a massive online community and some heavy backing. It tromps Prosody, which lacks LDAP and web ui, for integration and OpenFire for scalability. It also handles XMPP Jingle protocol for voice-chat support. Prosody has a very active community and developement and might someday sooner rather than later fix the lack of LDAP support.

SIP/PBX


Despite the fairly active core of solutions for VoIP including Asterisk, FreeSwitch, Yate and sipXecs. sipXecs is the only one of those that offers full integration with LDAP and XMPP (Jingle, presence and IM). However, it lacks flexibility at the VoIP level. It offers a distribution install (distributed through BitTorrent only) based on CentOS. The project is supported by the SIPFoundry foundation and Ezuce company, but hasn’t been very active lately. On the contrary, FreeSwitch offers an extremely active community and developpment. As shown by Baracuda Network’s Cudatel IP PBX Hardware, it is gaining popularity in the business sector. FreeSwitch also has two main Web UI satellite project: BlueBox/2600hz and FusionPBX. The former being more mature, but the latter gaining in popularity and offering an Ubuntu based distribution. FreeSwitch has one true show stopper: it doesn’t offer LDAP integration. Some people are claiming to be working on solutions, but nothing yet has emerged. It would however be possible to create an external real time bridge to LDAP/ActiveDirectory using mod_config_xml a web service configuration API. FreeSwitch runs off most major distributions, however it is packaged through a PPA under Ubuntu. LDAP Integration seems like it would be rather popular for FreeSwitch and something that would benefit a growing community. Asterisk is not to be ignored as it has a massive community and is by far the most used in the industry. It is quite flexible and capable, but definitely has its short comings.


http://truvoipbuzz.com/2010/08/on-premise-pbx-vs-hosted-pbx-selecting-right-phone-system-tutorial/

Freeswitch GUIs:
https://www.ohloh.net/p/compare?project_0=WikiPBX&project_1=fusionpbx&project_2=blue.box+project

ERP/Accounting

ERP/accounting is a critical business function. Here are several contenders:

  • Compiere Strengths: Compiere is an industrial strength ERP solution. It is a very mature, feature rich, and flexible application. Weaknesses: It is controlled/supported by a single company. It is released under a dual (open source/commercial) license. Compiere is java based, and uses either Oracle or Postgres backends.
  • Openbravo is a fork of Compiere. It has similar strengths and weaknesses compared to Compiere (powerful & mature, controlled by a single company & dual licenses).
  • ADempiere is also a fork of Compiere, but it is supported by a strong development community with a democratic community process. There is a great article about the advantages of loosely coupling Adempiere via an ESB here.
  • WebERP is a Apache/MySQL/PHP app that is very mature and well supported. It has fewer bells and whistles than Compiere and it's forks, but is still quite comprehensive. It has support for being loosly connected to a Wiki (Wacko Wiki). The out of the box wiki support is for wiki pages, not a tracker type CRM app.
  • SQL-Ledger is a perl/postgres based app. It was forked because of issues with the main developer (notice the "dot com" domain name).
  • Ledger SMB is the sql-ledger fork. There are a few heavyweight developers behind this project, but it moves very slowly...



https://www.ohloh.net/tags/erp/php
Activity level comparison

Client software

SIP/XMPP

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_IM_clients#Multiprotocol_clients
Should be cross-platform like Jitsi or QuteCom or Blink. Pidgin and Adium are definitely also popular choices covering all platform (and available as portables), but VoIP support is still lacking. Jingle voice and video support is however starting to be a reality, but for now only on linux (no windows or mac support). On the other side, Jitsi does not offer IRC, IBM Lotus or Novel GroupWise integration which is offered in Pidgin and Adium. Maybe it could be interesting to offer support (possibly at different levels though) for a couple of clients.

Ideally, runs on PortableApps.com


Browser

  • While any modern browser will do, Firefox or the SeaMonkey all-in-one internet application suite are candidates.

Email


Mobile

  • SIP client
  • VPN client (OpenVPN might be an issue on iPhones, I think there are only Jailbreak clients)
  • Mail client
  • Shared Calendar
  • Shared Contacts
  • etc.


To be decided

  • web hosting control panels
  • An SEO tool
    • Mostly useful for web agency use case
  • StatusNet Status updates/micro-blogging (distributed) or wish2258
    • cdrwhite: how about a few minimal extensions to the shoutbox stuff, we already have? shouts-per-user (also as rss), twitter-account and facebook-account as objects with object permissions, allowing a group to use one account)
      • marclaporte: Yes, that is an option, and making interoperable with StatusNet
  • Business Intelligence
  • How TRIM fits in
  • Remote surveillance / alarm system
  • High-volume newsletters
    • Tiki newletters are fine for small volumes, but they need to be improved for large volumes and the option to use an external service would be nice (because of spam protection)
  • Remote provisioning like Jitsi does it.


For a local server there should also be:

  • SAMBA server (authenticating against OpenLDAP)
  • NFS server (authenticating against OpenLDAP)
  • A VOIP-Solution (cdrwhite: Asterisk + FreePBX + tftp-Server for phones)
  • A solution for automated backups (cdrwhite: I use my own bash scripts with support for local folder/streamer, scp/ftp/ and all mountable folders, backing up MySQL, OpenLDAP and different folders, will shortly be (again) available at http://adminloesungen.de/

Comparison chart

REDIRECT plugin: The redirection to 'perspective 2' is disabled in preview mode.

History

Advanced
Information Version
Marc Laporte 86
View
Marc Laporte 85
View
Marc Laporte 84
View
Marc Laporte 83
View
Marc Laporte moving to decisions page 82
View
Marc Laporte Jitsi is awesome, and it already has Desktop sharing 81
View
Marc Laporte Backups, mail, Samba, etc. are part of ClearOS. 80
View
Marc Laporte That was moved to other page 79
View
Marc Laporte Moving to http://suite.tiki.org/Tiki+Suite+Features 78
View
Marc Laporte WebDAV is solved moving http://dev.jabbim.cz/jdisk to Tiki+Suite+component+interoperability 77
View
Marc Laporte http://www.jitsi.org/index.php/Development/SystrayControlModule so moving ideas to interoperability page 76
View
Marc Laporte Office Suite is at http://suite.tiki.org/Tiki+Suite+Components 75
View
Marc Laporte ClearOS which does mail and OpenLDAP 74
View
Marc Laporte 73
View
Marc Laporte 72
View
Marc Laporte Zentyal is very very interesting (and it bundles Asterisk and jabberd2!) and I hope/expect there will be something like Tiki Suite made with it in the future. However, in our case, we are PHP/MySQL/jQ 71
View
Marc Laporte 70
View
Marc Laporte Tiki7 parser is more strict 69
View
Marc Laporte 68
View
Marc Laporte 67
View
MatthL 66
View
MatthL 65
View
MatthL 64
View
MatthL 63
View
MatthL 62
View

Upcoming Events

1)  15 Aug 2024 14:00 GMT-0000
Tiki Roundtable Meeting
2)  19 Sep 2024 14:00 GMT-0000
Tiki Roundtable Meeting
3) 
Tiki birthday
4)  17 Oct 2024 14:00 GMT-0000
Tiki Roundtable Meeting
5)  21 Nov 2024 14:00 GMT-0000
Tiki Roundtable Meeting
6)  19 Dec 2024 14:00 GMT-0000
Tiki Roundtable Meeting