Loading...
 
Skip to main content

Features / Usability


Page staging permissions catch 22

After seeing the resolved issueQuestion regarding the missing category permissions I thought I'd try clearing the cache again and, behold, I was able to select the proper perms! This lead to a strange problem (aside from page staging not actually working on a windows server?).

Setting up category permissions according to the example in the documentationQuestion...

Categories perms:
Staging

  • Authors: tiki_p_view_categories
  • Authors: tiki_p_view_categorized
  • Authors: tiki_p_edit_categorized


Approved

  • Registered: tiki_p_view_categorized
  • Authors: tiki_p_view_categories
  • Approvers : tiki_p_edit_categorized See here.


If only approvers are assigned edit privileges, Authors don't get an edit link while viewing the approved page. But, if Authors DO have edit_categorized perms, they are also invited to approve changes after editing! (Even if they do not have rename, remove & rollback perms.).

Anyone else see this? I'm looking for another reason this might happen (and still looking for why page staging may not work)

Hi,
I have came across the very same problem.
Did you ever find an answer for it?
Thanks,
ALan

Naw... never came up with a solution. Which is really too bad, I love the whole staging concept. There just doesn't seem to be any real implementations of it out there. Otherwise, I'm sure the issue would've been addressed. It looks like I'll be abandoning tiki anyway as our workplace is having lotus quickr rammed down it's throat. A shame really, I was getting to like tiki...

Cheers,

Lucas

I ahve the very same problem. I love staging and approval, but with this bug - or say - inconsistency the whole staging in Tiki is not working properly.... The core problem is that while assigning tiki_p_edit_categorized to registered or anonymous visitors they can as well approve pages although they do not have they permissions to do so!

I have been trying around for days now... it is not my configuration, it seems to be a Tiki bug.... Take away the tiki_p_edit_categorized and they can´t approve anymore, but as well they can´t edit anymore!!!!

Already found two Tiki bugs in the past (which I could fix be changing the code)... this seems to be the third one....

Marco
Strongly watching out for Tikiwiki 3.0


Well, yeah, there are real implementations of page staging out there. It's used by the Tikiwiki installation that runs support.mozilla.org, so I guess glitches here are due to incomplete backporting of the modifications made by the Mozilla team. I'm not sure what the status of this is. Also, of course, the Mozilla project is in full control of the hardware it's running on, so doesn't have to test or accomodate all the variations in server OSs and configurations, etc. But this is a desired feature so will be worked on and improved for general use.

-- Gary