Loading...
 
Skip to main content

Features / Usability


Uploading images to the Wiki

TikiWiki6.5 on a commercial hosting package.

On a wiki page, if I am using the Wiki editor, when I click on the insert image icon, a box comes up with a large number of fields that can take data. One of these does allow the input of an id from an Image Gallery. However the user HAS to have previously uploaded the image and know the id to be a able to insert it into the wiki page.

If I am editing the page using the WYSIWYG editor, clicking on the insert image icon opens an "Image properties" dialogue box where you can enter a URL or hit the "Browse Server" button. If you hit the Browse Server button another large html window opens with essentially, the ability to browse the File Galleries ONLY, OR upload a file from disk.

If I choose the upload from disk option, it appears that the file is automatically put into the File Gallery root folder, irrespective of the fact that in Admin wiki features, Pictures is ticked and File Galleries is unticked so the images should go to /img/wiki_up.

For the ordinary user who is trying to use the site that has been setup for them (not for computer literate people or hardcore coders), the system as it stands is unintuitive, confusing and unhelpful. I find it so, and my users tell me the same.

If the images would just go to "/img/wiki_up" from either editor that would be great. Ordinary users could just select an image form their disk, hit insert and it would appear in the page. For most users simple and effective, and that is what they want, when editing wiki pages.

If there could be an advanced option to save the image to EITHER an Image Gallery OR a File Gallery instead , that would seem straightforward (and other CMSs offer this) Of course all the other image options could be included in the advanced option for those that need that level of control.

On the practical level:
Can someone tell me how I can change something somewhere, so that users wanting to upload an image into the wiki, can choose to save it to an IMAGE Gallery, preferably THEIR image gallery or the "wiki_up" folder, not the root folder, and not the File Gallery.


From this readers will surmise that I am biased in favour of images and I admit to that to a certain extent, but I would say that if you want to make the claim of being the most full featured and integrated CMS, then I would presume that a good Image Gallery is an essential component. However what I really would like is for Tiki to be stable and easy to use for the ordinary user as well as the IT professional.

Somewhere along the line, the tiki organisers/committe have decided to go with a single file repository for all files. I personally want the Image gallery as a separate option in Tiki and I would like it to be well developed in preference to some of the latest features. That is my opinion anyway.

I hope these comments will be viewed as constructive, as I think that Tiki has great potential but I do think that Version 6 (and I have used Tiki since 1.9) should have sorted out inserting images into the wiki by now.

.

You should be aware that the Image Gallery was deprecated several versions ago.

The default behavior is to use the File Gallery to store images. If you want images stored in ../img/wiki_up/ then you need to de-select the option on the Admin: Wiki features page.

HTH,

- RickQuestion | My Tiki Blog | My Tiki UserPage

Tiki for Dummies SmartiesQuestion, the best (and only) Tiki beginner's guide! Learn more...Question

Tiki EssentialsQuestion, the best-selling book for Tiki! Learn more...Question

Need more help? Try Tiki for Dummies SmartiesQuestion: A beginner's guide and Tiki EssentialsQuestion: What all Smarties need to know about Tiki Wiki CMS Groupware.

Hi Rick,

Thanks for the reply.

I am aware that Image Gallery was deprecated. As I say I think it is a poor idea. I think having image galleries and document galleries all in together does not work well and ordinary people who use the website find it confusing even with the improved nested folder display system in File Galleries.

Also when going to a gallery with images, one must hit the “Browse” button to see the thumbnails. All this is sort of OK IF you know all these things, but to the uninitiated user they are confusing and unintuitive.

As a matter of interest can you explain why the decision to not have the Image Galleries as a separate option? And if that decision has been made why are Image Galleries still available as an option? Be done with it and remove them entirely so there is no question about it, and those of us who need good image handling as part of a community website will know unequivocally that we have to go elsewhere.

On the question of inserting images into wiki pages or anywhere else for that matter, he current options are confusing and unhelpful based on different behaviours in the two editors. In wiki mode you CAN insert images from the image galleries. In WYSIWYG you cannot.

In WYSIWYG (it appears - but correct me if I am wrong) you can ONLY upload an image from disk to the root folder of the File galleries area. Yes, you can then move it somewhere else, but why should you need to?

If Image Galleries ARE still present, then does it not seem obvious that when a user wants to upload a new image from their HD that they can do so on the spot (ie not have previously uploaded it to a gallery) and that they can then elect to save it to a folder location of their choice in EITHER Image OR File Galleries OR have it go into the image dump area, i.e /img/wiki_up/?

As mentioned the option to have images go to /img/wiki_up/ does not work for me even with full access permissions to that folder on the server.

Anyhow, to those who take umbrage at any criticism, I AM most appreciative of the general quality and freeness of Open Source and to those who work unpaid to improve it.

It can be better and so can the documentation!