Loading...
 
Skip to main content

Features / Usability


Newsletter using "groups"

I'm using TikiWiki 5.3 Many groups were created to regroup the users. Let's say GRP1 and GRP2 GRP1 inherits the rights of GRP2, but both have different users. When I build a Newsletter for GRP1, it seems to include also GRP2 users. Is this the correct behavior ? Gaston

2011-02-24 08:45 Rick Sapir-3
This sounds correct to me.
If GRP1 inherits GRP2 (that is, GRP2 is "inside" of GRP1) then yes sending
to GRP1 would include GRP2.
-R

2011-02-24 12:33 Gaston Huot
Tks Rick
Sounds bizarre to me...
The fact that GRP1 inherits the rights of GRP2 should not make users in GRP2 included with users in GRP1 . "Rights" and "users" are two different things.
How then would I send a message to just GRP1 ?
What do you think ?
Gaston

2011-02-24 19:30 Rick Sapir-3
I don't think that the inheritance is limited to permissions. AFAIK, if a
user is a member of GroupA that includes GroupB, then the user is a de-facto
member of GroupB, too.
I typically create two sets of groups for my Tiki projects:
- One set of groups is for permissions
- The other set of groups is for content access
This is how I'm able to to send messages to members of just a single group
(i.e., one of the "content" groups).
-R

2011-02-24 19:57 Gaston Huot
I don't see the interest of having GRP1 including GRP2 users (but I understand clearly the interest of having GRP1 inheriting GRP2 rights...
If I need to send a newsletter to GRP1 and GRP2, I can specify both groups. It seems a little weird to me.
Would the modification to not include any groups if not specifically mentioned difficult to make ?
Gaston

2011-02-24 20:10 Marc Laporte-3
I remember such a discussion a while back with respect to group inclusion being desired for most thing, but not the newsletter.
I don't remember what the conclusion was, if any.

2011-02-24 23:28 Gaston Huot
In the "admin group section", if I export GRP1 Group, it will result in a list of members of GRP1 alone (not GRP2).
Why would it be different with the newsletter ?
Gaston

Am I the only one to think this is a bug (or the only one to use the Newsletters)?

For comments.

Gaston

huogas wrote:

I'm using TikiWiki 5.3 Many groups were created to regroup the users. Let's say GRP1 and GRP2 GRP1 inherits the rights of GRP2, but both have different users. When I build a Newsletter for GRP1, it seems to include also GRP2 users. Is this the correct behavior ?

The fact that GRP1 inherits the rights of GRP2 should not make users in GRP2 included with users in GRP1 . "Rights" and "users" are two different things.
How then would I send a message to just GRP1 ?

In the "admin group section", if I export GRP1 Group, it will result in a list of members of GRP1 alone (not GRP2).
Why would it be different with the newsletter ?
Gaston